User blog comment:Starsong Meadowsweet/User blog:StarsongMeadowsweet/@comment-Essay:Why the Killing of Rose wasn't Justified/@comment-1884658-20100707045625

I see your logic, and this is really a very well-developed essay. Actually, I had guessed near the beggining that Rose would die, and I didn't get it. I wondered why he even put her in there if he was just gonna kill her off. I like your writing.