User blog comment:Ferretmaiden/Rose and Martin alternative ending/@comment-1808183-20100216030336

That is something to think about. I have thought about this, but a little differently (I.E Both of them living). If that< did happen, Martin would have gone to noonvale, and lived with Rose, Redwall would have never been made, ect. But, since Abbess Germaine left her abbey anyway, and they had the whole Corim thing going, Redwall still might have been made, just without Martin. But maybe in life we shouldn't think about the 'what if's' that much. I was so sad when Rose died. Great essay, great thinking! :)