Talk:Magger

Does anyone feel like Magger's death was pretty violent? I know many deaths in the series are, but his was especially...he was beaten savagely until he was yanked upright and beheaded. Another thing is, was he dead when he was beaten or when he was beheaded? Because the book says "...[he beat Magger with the rope] until he was certain Magger was [b]finished[/b]" and I don't know if that means too weak to attack or dead.