Thread:D2r/@comment-1859920-20120718142020

Heya D2r. I've some imput regarding your blog on Unanswered Questions of Redwall. One is in the form of an answer. Oh, and if you're wondering why this' as a message, its because your blog already has 331 comments and I couldn't be sure you'd see it. Anyhow, here goes. For questions 2 and 4 regarding mines or mining. I do have an answer or, better yet, a quote that may satisfy the question in part. This quote is from Redwall when Matthias, Constance, and co. first spotted Cluny coming down the path. Well, its after they returned to the abbey and old Methuselah was reading through some records involving Cluny. Here's the quote:

"... news of a mine disaster, caused by a large savage sea rat with an extrordinary tail. It seems that this rat - Cluny they called him - wanted to settle his army in the mine. The badgers and other creatures who owned the mines, drove them out. Cluny returned by night, and with his band of rats gnawed and undermined much of the wooden shoring. This caused the mine to collapse the next day, killing the owners."

Alright, and secondly, I just wanted to say that I think Question 11 is an unnessessary one. There is no evidence that Urgan and Silvamord even attempted to produce offspring. For that matter, the question is about as random as asking why Iris and Rab Streambattle didn't produce offspring either. 