User blog comment:Brigadier Barty/The Greatest Threat to Redwall Abbey/@comment-26141072-20150329025844

Ooooh interesting! I *squirm* used Astar's outline for my own. (so lazy) and I'll also rate them from 1-10. XD

Cluny: If it weren't for Matthias, the shrews and Warbeak, he would have one. 9-10

General Ironbeak: Once again, if it weren't for Kite Redstryke, he would have won. However, he was killed by a half-injured bird so I'd say he rates lower than Cluny, around 6-10

Greypatch: Although he had some good ideas, he, unlike Ferhago or the others, could not stand up against even just THREE hares. So he'd get 5 out of ten.

Swartt Sixclaw: Well he was definitely scared off easily. . . 3/10

Damug Warfang: He was fairly gullible, but he had superior numbers and more so I'd say. . . around 7/10

Marlfoxes: If they had been trying to conquer Redwall they probably could have succeeded. 8/10

Vallug and Eefera: Few in number, yet they had the Redwallers bottled up in the Abbey building. 7/10

Kurda and Plugg Firetail: I'm a bit biased since I love Plugg Firetail, but in attacking Redwall, I can't say they did a very good job so probably 6/10

Gulo: He definitely caused a lot of damage. . . 7/10

Vizka Longtooth: He was smart but I never really liked him, so 7/10

Korvus Skurr: He definitely lost his touch after a while. *ahem* 4/10

The Sable Quean: She COULD have won. Although the Redwallers are smart, the hostages were an ingenious idea, and she discovered (and used) Brockhall after a long time without knowledge of where it was. 8/10