User blog comment:Martin2/Essay:Is Madd from Taggerung Fwirl's dead mother?(Rebuttal)/@comment-1209332-20100307035745

I believe it did not say Deyna was shot in the heart. He was shot in the chest area, which probably tore a lot of muscle and maybe broke some bones, which left him curable. Also with 4, your very argument invalidates that point. If you say something not explicitly states is not true, than Madd cannot possibly be Fwirl's mother. Also, how does one enter a log devoid of holes? 1&2: So you have perfect memory of what you say over a seven month period? 5: Consistency on writing is what authors get paid to do. 6: Granted. But remember that Fwirl's mother died in south Mossflower, slightly East of Redwall Abbey. Madd was found west of Redwall Abbey, adjacent to the River Moss. Unless Fwirl's Mother crawled several miles while unconscious, or was taken by the vermin after they left somehow, or is a super-squirrel with teleportation abilities (That's fairly plausible. I mean the vermin taking her) it's impossible. Also, see point un-numbered.