User blog comment:Sandingomm the Wildcat/Top 5 Redwall Books/@comment-39162126-20190922155105

Just read the the article; frankly I’d put Loamhedge at the bottom. There were too many Mary Sues, the plot was dull, and many of the characters were forgettable. The villain was even forgettable as he had no real motives at all. But I agree, Mossflower is one of the best Redwall books.