User blog comment:D2r/Was Veil ultimately Redeemed?/@comment-3474228-20111225183255/@comment-4507006-20111230124657

I would like to refute a few points.

1. Veil did not trip in front of Bryony. His exact words: "You leave her alone...uhh!" In bluestripe the wild's essay, he points out that Veil Is a vermin, and had no good beast INSTINCTS. So, his saving of Bryony was voluntary.

2. Veil never killed anyone like a terrorist. The only bad things he did was making Myrtle sick and attempting, not killing, to kill Ole Hoffy. So I think saving Bryony was enough to redeem himself.