User blog comment:Brigadier Barty/The Greatest Threat to Redwall Abbey/@comment-2142396-20150326181638

That’s a fun game you came up with, Barty! I’ll rate the villains threatening Redwall from 1 to 10.

Cluny: Came dangerously close to winning, and he was really clever. 8 of 10.

General Ironbeak: A formidable enemy, but not a real threat. 5 of 10.

Greypatch: Same as Ironbeak. 5 of 10.

Swartt Sixclaw: Ran away after the first skirmish and didn’t even reach Redwall. 2 of 10.

Damug Warfang: Tricked into accepting Redwallers’ terms easily, but this is compensated by the huge numbers of his army. He had a high chance of winning if it wasn’t for Cregga. 9 of 10.

Marlfoxes: So full of tricks and clever ruses, they almost succeeded. 8 of 10.

Vallug and Eefera: For just two beasts, they managed to lay quite a siege on the Abbey. 5 0f 10.

Kurda and Plugg Firetail: Their attack is deflected easily, besides, they were more interested in the treasure than in the Abbey. 4 of 10.

Raga Bol: A formidable enemy who posed a real threat, but not as effective as others. 6 of 10.

Gulo: A savage enemy who compensates the lack of strategic thinking with power and cruelty. 7 of 10.

Vizka Longtooth: A smart villain who could seize the command over Brownrats. He had a high chance of winning in the battle on the plateau. 8 of 10.

Korvus Skurr: Send glowing birds on a secret mission, then make a deal with the mad snake. You’re a genius, Korvus. 2 of 10.

The Sable Quean: Her plan with the hostages almost succeeded in defeating the Abbey without an actual battle, and then she could seize the moment and almost win a real battle. 9 of 10.

So, Damug Warfang and the Sable Quean take the first place, with Cluny, Marlfoxes and Vizka Longtooth sharing the second, Gulo on the third.