User blog comment:LordTBT/News:The Future of Redwall/@comment-3195118-20110526063141/@comment-1298206-20110604141505

Not quite. Cluny had the upper claw through almost the whole book until the end. He's the only villain who has gotten that close to capturing Redwall! Slagar deceived them and got away with it until the end of the book where he was killed. Ungatt Trunn took over Salamandastron, but briefly.